| Platinum | Fratelli Village Pizzeria |
| Platinum | Pasta Tutti Giorni |
| Gold | Lamanna's Bakery |
| Silver | Nova Ristorante |
| Bronze | Francesca Italian Bakery & Delicatessen |
| Top Pick | Agincourt Bakery & Italian Kitchen |
| Top Pick | Donatello Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Remezzo Italian Bistro |